The man he killed meaning. In Thomas Hardy's "The Man He Killed," what is the speaker's motivation to accomplish whatever this speaker is trying to accomplish? 2022-12-09

The man he killed meaning Rating: 9,9/10 710 reviews

The poem "The Man He Killed" by Thomas Hardy is a poignant commentary on the brutality and futility of war. The speaker in the poem is a soldier who has killed another man in battle. As he reflects on the incident, he realizes that the man he killed was just like him, with similar hopes and dreams, and that he could have easily been in the other man's place.

The poem is structured as a dramatic monologue, with the speaker addressing the reader directly as he confesses his thoughts and feelings about the killing. The first stanza describes the scene of the battle, with the speaker saying that he "shot" the man "dead" because he was "enemies" with him. The use of the verb "shot" and the phrase "dead" convey the violence and finality of the act, emphasizing the gravity of the situation.

The second stanza is where the speaker begins to reflect on the man he killed. He says that the man was "young," "fair," and "just of his prime," suggesting that he was in the prime of his life and had much to live for. The speaker also notes that the man had "quaint and curious" buttons on his coat, perhaps indicating that he had a personal style or was a man of means.

In the third stanza, the speaker expresses his regret for killing the man, saying that he "had [him] dead" and that the man was "as brave" as he was. The use of the past tense "had" and the adjective "brave" suggest that the speaker is no longer in a state of combat and has had time to reflect on the implications of his actions. The speaker goes on to say that he and the man he killed could have been "friends" if they had "met" under different circumstances, implying that the only thing separating them was the fact that they were fighting on opposing sides of a war.

The final stanza of the poem is perhaps the most poignant, as the speaker says that he "should ask [the man's] pardon" if he "knew" him. This line suggests that the speaker is not only regretful for killing the man, but that he also recognizes the fundamental humanity of his enemy. The speaker goes on to say that he cannot ask for forgiveness because the man is "dead," indicating that the opportunity for reconciliation has been lost forever.

In conclusion, "The Man He Killed" is a powerful meditation on the senselessness of war and the human cost of violence. Through the speaker's reflections on the man he killed, Hardy highlights the fundamental similarities between enemies and the tragedy of lives lost in conflict. The poem serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of understanding and empathy in times of conflict.

Why does the poet think that war is quaint and curious in "The Man He Killed"?

the man he killed meaning

The original title of the movie is Old Man. He spent his early life in a rural atmosphere that has an influence on the subject matters of his novels. The write-up is about the troubled speaker who is unable to reconcile himself to the fact that he killed a man who would otherwise be his friend. Works Cited Abdulsalm, Hamid B. He says if they had met in an inn they would of shared many drinks. The speaker, being poor is enlisted as an infantryman for the frontline, who is supposed to take orders from the superior authority.


Next

Literary Analysis of "The Man He Killed" by T. Hardy

the man he killed meaning

Had they known the result; they would probably look for alternative ways to solve their monetary challenges. Posted on 2012-02-23 by a guest. In the poem, Hardy puts himself in the perspective of a common people and asks bigger questions regarding the purpose of the war in general except destruction and loss. A dramatic monologue, the poem's speaker recounts having to kill a man in war with whom he had found himself "face to face. The scoundrel says that he went hunting to get food for both of them. How might those differences change our attitudes toward his death? It was just fear of the ghost of the man he killed for having an affair with Jeanie.

Next

The Man He Killed Poem Summary and Analysis

the man he killed meaning

. The speaker, in the first stanza, wonders what would be the condition if they met in different, normal circumstances. At the end of the film, the old man sees his wife in a box. The best he can come up with is a pat answer: because he was my enemy, I killed him. What are they hiding from each other? It appears as though he has set aside his misgivings.

Next

The Man He Killed by Thomas Hardy Summary and Analysis

the man he killed meaning

GradeSaver, 19 February 2021 Web. Yes; quaint and curious war is! The box contains a photograph of a red-haired woman with piercing eyes. Although his verse was not nearly as successful as his novels, Hardy continued to focus on his poetry and published seven more books of verse before his death, developing his confidence and technical competence. Although he is considered a Victorian writer, he was influenced by Romanticism, especially by William Wordsworth and Charles Dickens. In " In the third stanza of the poem, Hardy struggles to identify a good reason as to why, in the context of a war, one man might kill another man whom he does not know and with whom he has no personal quarrel.

Next

In Thomas Hardy's "The Man He Killed," what is the speaker's motivation to accomplish whatever this speaker is trying to accomplish?

the man he killed meaning

Hardy uses irony to reveal that the killing, and the war at large, was not justified. He inherited the love for reading and books from his mother. The contrast is all the more poignant because from the very start of the poem, the narrator reveals himself as preferring the inn, although he has committed an act completely antithetical to its spirit. Rhyming Scheme: The man He Killed is a five-stanza poem by Thomas Hardy having a rhyming Scheme of abab, cdcd, efef, ghgh, ijij. In the box is a photograph of her with a seahorse. The Man He Killed, by Thomas Hardy, is a dramatic monologue in the speech of returned soldier from war. The speaker begins by stating that he had no personal quarrel with the man he killed.


Next

The Man He Killed Analysis Thomas Hardy : Summary Explanation Meaning Overview Essay Writing Critique Peer Review Literary Criticism Synopsis Online Education

the man he killed meaning

So we can assume that he made up the story about killing the leopard right after he killed the Genie. The tone is somber since meeting in a bar would have allowed the speaker to have a nice moment but it is obvious, they encountered each other in a different setting. The Dorset man is an outsider in South Africa, an invader; the Boer settler is at home—already in that very place where, under other circumstances, he might meet his British fellow as a drinking companion. He is very surprised to see the young man at his door, so he feels somewhat threatened. The use of literary elements makes his poems interesting and with a depth of meaning about his social, geographical context Literary Analysis The title is a significant part of any write-up as it gives an idea about the prose. He stops, and feels unsure of what he means.

Next

Summary of The Man He Killed by Thomas Hardy: 2022

the man he killed meaning

We soon see that both of them are very comfortable talking to each other. The box is important because it has to do with the murder of his wife. The Bible had long been considered the final word on how the universe and all things within had come into existence. The extended length of these third lines may mimic a deeper dramatic weight given to these lines. At the same time, these stanzas lend several subtle inflections to that perplexing fact.

Next

The Man He Killed

the man he killed meaning

Sparknotes bookrags the meaning summary overview critique of explanation pinkmonkey. The adults announce the war, and it is youth who suffers. There are only two heroes the rest of the characters will appear for a short time, like ghosts. Although he is still conscious that this reason is not good enough and does not excuse him for what he did. Immediately there is a feeling that the box is connected with her murder.

Next