Pros of civil disobedience. Civil Disobedience: The Montgomery Bus Boycott 2022-12-31

Pros of civil disobedience Rating: 6,4/10 1493 reviews

Civil disobedience is the act of deliberately breaking a law that is perceived as unjust in order to bring about social change. It is a form of protest that has been used throughout history by people who believe that they have a moral obligation to resist laws that are harmful or unfair. There are several pros to civil disobedience, which are outlined below.

First and foremost, civil disobedience can be an effective way to bring about social change. When people break a law that they believe is unjust, they are making a statement and drawing attention to the issue at hand. This can be especially powerful when the act of disobedience is carried out by a large group of people, as it can create a sense of solidarity and show the strength of their conviction. Civil disobedience can also be a way to raise awareness about important issues and bring them to the forefront of public consciousness.

Another pro of civil disobedience is that it can challenge the status quo and bring about necessary reform. When people are willing to break the law in order to stand up for what they believe in, it can put pressure on lawmakers and other authorities to address the issues at hand. This can lead to the creation of new laws or policies that better reflect the values and needs of the people.

Additionally, civil disobedience can be a way for individuals to assert their own moral beliefs and values, even if they are in conflict with the law. When people are willing to stand up for what they believe in, it can be a powerful expression of personal freedom and autonomy. It can also be a way for individuals to take personal responsibility for their actions and be held accountable for the consequences of their disobedience.

Finally, civil disobedience can be a way to bring about peaceful change. While it may involve breaking the law, it is typically carried out in a non-violent manner and is meant to bring about change through peaceful means. This can be a more effective and less destructive way to bring about social change, as it avoids the use of violence and allows for a more constructive dialogue.

In conclusion, there are several pros to civil disobedience. It can be an effective way to bring about social change, challenge the status quo, assert personal values, and bring about peaceful change. While it may involve breaking the law, it can be a powerful and necessary tool for bringing about positive change in society.

19 Major Pros and Cons of Civil Disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

Arguments for Obedience and Disobedience To explain the first argument where obedience is good and disobedience is bad, human beings follow rules so as not to against the law or against the rules. Modern-Day Examples of Civil Disobedience In recent times too, civil disobedience has been used as a tool to fight against injustice, all over the world. Not every just cause can be pursued through the courts e. For an individual to be free from societal norms and pressures, they had to be disobedient. The contribution that Malaysia's nascent civil society made to the anti-authoritarian struggles is widely recognised today, not only locally but also internationally.

Next

Pros And Cons Of Civil Disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

By doing so they set an example of illegality and contempt for law and order which others, with less worthy causes or no cause at all, will follow. Civil disobedience positively impacts free society because these acts spread awareness on unjust laws, and cause the governments to double check laws and question if they are really necessary. This especially became true as more and more people continued to rebel against authoritative figures who were charged with developing their worlds. Although not as tyrannical a government, the British monarchy also took away rights from the American colonists prior to the revolutionary war. Example Till a few decades ago, South Africa had apartheid rule: rule that stressed on racial segregation through the legislation. What Is Thoreau's Claim In Civil Disobedience 749 Words 3 Pages He says that people have a duty to civil disobedience; however, civil disobedience is not always enough to change anything in the government.

Next

5 Pros and Cons of Civil Disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

Disobedience is therefore seen as a negative act that affects the institutions in the society Passini and Morselli 100. Rosa Parks, amongst dozens of other outspoken African Americans, led a movement in Montgomery which had tens of thousands of African Americans stop riding the bus. Thoreau furthermore exclaims in his essays that the Americans citizens should have followed what power they thought was right, like their conscience, instead of the wrong of the government. List of Cons of Civil Disobedience 1. She has been arrested multiple times for her participation in peaceful protests, but shows no signs of stopping.

Next

Historical and Recent Examples of Civil Disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

It concentrates on why a person remains obedient to the governmental law although he or she believes it to be prejudiced. Martin Luther King Jr. Such people, Thoreau argued, accept government as a "necessary evil. Even Gandhi inspired violent counterparts when India was on a quest toward independence. Then peaceful students were pepper-sprayed by officers at the University of California-Davis, further reinforcing how people felt.

Next

Civil Disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

Many people who act in civil disobedience break laws in order to protest something. Thoreau ultimately sent the message that if following what was right and following your heart really believes in like the right of doing right; then let it be and so live life in spite of what one thinks. This was not only a victory for the people of Alabama, but it also led to more participation in activism and civil rights movements all around the country. Civil disobedience establishes religious freedoms. Definition of Obedience and Disobedience To better understand the concept of disobedience and obedience a definition of each is required.

Next

Civil Disobedience: The Montgomery Bus Boycott

pros of civil disobedience

Even Jesus acknowledged this disadvantage when discussing how family dynamics would change when belief systems changed in Luke 12. Civil Disobedience was published in 1849. This act of disobedience affected the development of man in the world as obedience and disobedience co-existed together in the world. It can create real change. Some historians argue that the illegal activities of the suffragettes in the UK in the early 20th century actually set back their cause. It is the kind of obedience that responds to outside thoughts and power.

Next

The Pros And Cons Of Civil Disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

Thoreau also believed that the government does best if it does not rule over the people. Breaking any law will defeat the purpose of the movement, get people imprisoned and there can be jail time involved. Scientific American, 193 31-35 , 1955. In a democracy civil disobedience cannot be justified. There will always be a few that become radicalized because of their support against acts of civil disobedience, just as there are those who become radicalized when seeking equal justice for everyone involved. In the 1950s-1960s, segregation was rampant in the United States, especially in the South.

Next

Civil Disobedience: Advantages and Disadvantages

pros of civil disobedience

Although it was considered an American duty to pay taxes to support the country's decisions, Thoreau did not believe that the Mexican-American War was the right direction towards prosperity, so he risked the consequence of prison rather than succumb to the directions given to him which would falsify his own ideals. It is a tool that can be used to make a difference. Individuals who practice autonomous obedience exercise their own judgment and follow their own perceptions rather than those of other people. Although there is always a physical risk involved with civil disobedience, anyone at any age can create the change they wish to see in the world. History tells us the tales of both kinds of civil disobedience. Over the years, acts of civil disobedience have helped to shape how the world perceives religion and spirituality. These significant pros and cons of civil disobedience allow for a fair overview of such actions, as it does become necessary from time to time for the general public to rise up against an unjust government.

Next

Pros and cons of civil disobedience

pros of civil disobedience

All laws have been challenged by someone at one point leading to jail time, and some people that have been imprisoned did time because they stood up to a law they broke that was unjust. Civil disobedience cannot be an armed struggle. He believed that people should practice their right of refusal by using civil disobedience towards the government. This a simple fact which has been proven many times by history all around the world. The only obligation which I have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think right. We must obey the law even if we think it is wrong, or anarchy will result.


Next