Affirmative action in education pros and cons. Affirmative Action Pros And Cons 2023-01-07

Affirmative action in education pros and cons Rating: 6,6/10 1630 reviews

Affirmative action in education refers to policies and practices that aim to increase the representation of historically marginalized groups, such as racial and ethnic minorities, women, and individuals with disabilities, in educational institutions. Affirmative action can take a variety of forms, including targeted recruitment and outreach, the use of race or ethnicity as a factor in admissions decisions, and the implementation of diversity initiatives.

There are several arguments in favor of affirmative action in education. One is that it helps to address the historical and ongoing effects of discrimination and disadvantage that have resulted in underrepresentation of certain groups in higher education. By providing opportunities for underrepresented groups to access and succeed in higher education, affirmative action can help to create a more diverse and inclusive educational environment, which can have a range of benefits for all students.

Another argument in favor of affirmative action is that it can help to create a more diverse and representative workforce. By increasing the number of underrepresented groups in higher education, affirmative action can help to create a more diverse pool of candidates for future employment in a variety of fields. This can be especially important in fields where diversity is particularly important, such as education, healthcare, and social work.

However, there are also arguments against affirmative action in education. One concern is that it may result in reverse discrimination against individuals who are not members of historically marginalized groups. This can occur when a person who is otherwise qualified is passed over in favor of a less qualified member of an underrepresented group.

Another concern is that affirmative action may perpetuate the idea that certain groups are not capable of achieving success on their own merit. This can lead to a lack of motivation and a decrease in effort for students who may feel that their success is due to affirmative action rather than their own abilities.

Overall, the debate over affirmative action in education is complex and multifaceted. While it has the potential to create a more diverse and inclusive educational environment and workforce, it also has the potential to result in reverse discrimination and may perpetuate the idea that certain groups are not capable of achieving success on their own merit.

Affirmative Action: what are the pros and cons? : NeutralPolitics

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Doing the same amount of work may not always lead to the same results, for majorities and minorities, which opponents argue is unequal. Texas Argumentative Analysis 350 Words 2 Pages. Duke Power Company case is relevant for this argument. In 1972, it passed both houses of Congress and was submitted to the state legislatures for ratification. Is that 17-year-old being unfairly rewarded because she or he won the Luck of the Sperm roulette game? In 2007, two female high school students applied to the University of Texas; one of the girls being Miss Abigail N. Diversity is important and does have its place. Why should a richer minority receive advantages over a poor white male? Give more than just a headline.

Next

Affirmative action: pros and cons

affirmative action in education pros and cons

While they do have lower average incomes and higher percentages in lower income groups, it is quite untrue to say that they qualify as a generally poor group in need of financial balancing. I had a acquaintance ask me by the way, I'm a minority why his father has to hire black people if he's uncomfortable around them. Minorities who benefit from affirmative action often have weaker credentials, but there is fairly little solid evidence that their labor market performance is weaker. Rather than focusing on affirmative action programming, many believe more work should be put into directly ending personal bias. So basically, any reasonable opinion on AA is going to require context.

Next

Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action In Colleges

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Given all of the above, it follows that the Claremont Institute in particular and perhaps not only the Claremont Institute is misrepresenting the issue of the United States' government's affirmative action policies. Affirmative action has little influence on admissions decisions at the majority of universities and colleges. In my opinion no. Political campaign and politicians were trying to go against voters from supporting the Equal Rights Amendment but Phyllis Schlafly attracted the attention of the nation and she points out that equality of rights under the law should not be denied by the United States or by any state because of gender. By being need-blind, and instead using AA as their bias for balance, many schools imply that Hispanics and African-Americans are almost all poor. The university uses race as an aid to admit minorities and increase diversity instead of accepting well qualified individuals.

Next

The Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action

affirmative action in education pros and cons

This mode of reasoning is, simply put, much more reasonable. So here you have a situation where a black kid is getting into a way better school than he should have been able to. A rich black kid has the opportunity to double dip when it comes to AA based purley off race. To be clear, I'm not advocating for AA but explains the rationale as I see it, spherically in the context you ask for Edit: For more on why it's important bring individuals into the middle class in addition to groups read "Whistling Vivaldi" for Stereotype threat. This distinction has rights and benefits. What are pros of affirmative action? And this statement goes back a bit further. I appreciate this post and you exploring different sides of the argument.

Next

Affirmative Action Pros And Cons

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Sole exception: if you cannot find specific information after a thorough online search, you may post a request for sources. But we did have a few minorities - a couple of black kids from very rich families. Minorities attending the University of Michigan have dwindled heavily over the years since …show more content… I am hopeful that affirmative action will be a way of the past soon enough. As a result, they are not adequately prepared for the rigors of top-tier universities. Reddit will pounce on you with the cons, so here are the pros. In 1961, President John F. A first-of-its-kind study of the impact of reservations in public sector jobs on productivity and efficiency has shown that the affirmative action did not reduce productivity in any sector, but had, in fact, raised it in some areas.

Next

What Is Affirmative Action Pros And Cons?

affirmative action in education pros and cons

So in the end you're taking in the less qualified applicant. Those who support it believe that higher education flourishes whenever people of different races, ethnicities, and social groups mingle on the same campus 314. The idea that you can work hard and make your way out of poverty isn't totally accepted because of the distrust of the 'ruling class. . Recent post: What Country Still Has Slavery? Overall, affirmative action redistributes jobs and student slots towards minorities and females, though these effects are not very large. Supporters of affirmative action argue that it is necessary in order to promote diversity and to compensate for Historically, affirmative action in higher education has been contentious and contentious.

Next

The Use Of Affirmative Action In Education: Pros And Cons

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Some people argue that affirmative action does not apply to universities because the purpose of affirmative action is to address past discrimination and universities do not have a history of discrimination. As part of its lawsuit against the UT-Austin admissions program, SFFA also resurrected its race-conscious admissions lawsuit. Instead of being viewed as an equal or more, people will be even more racist, believing they only got the job or got into that school because of their race. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Kennedy proposed a policy to reduce racial disparity.

Next

The Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action In College Admissions

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Texas Argumentative Analysis 350 Words 2 Pages The Supreme Court emphasized the learning benefits from a diverse student body. As I recall from studying the AA years back, that is a problem more to do with employers than the law. According to authors, race-conscious admissions do not solve racial disparities. And the results will only be seen 15-20 years down the road which means they will not get the credit. A 6-2 vote from the court system "backed" the University of Michigan for their ban of affirmative action. Blacks my people less so. But we've gotten to point, politically, where people scream "socialism! It can give opportunities to those that wouldn't otherwise get them.

Next

The Cons of Affirmative Action

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Despite the fact that affirmative action is still in place and well practiced in the United States today, nine states have banned it. In support of affirmative-admissions policies, a coalition of diverse students spoke out in the Harvard case. In order to meet racial admission quotas, a school may admit a student who does not necessarily meet all the requirements. No - in fact we welcome and encourage any viewpoint to engage in discussion. They get a comfortable socio-economic status growing up, and still get the benefits of AA even though they already benefited.

Next

Pros And Cons Of Race

affirmative action in education pros and cons

Why shouldn't we transfer from AA to a heavier opportunity based system that allows anybody to climb the ladder in life? I think it is about helping those that actually need it versus those that have been able to have a good education and financial resources to lead them in a certain direction. As I researched the issue more, it became apparent to me that diversity is truly important to our learning experiences while in college. Statements of fact must cite Submissions that do not include sources will be rejected. June 23, 2016 — The US Supreme Court upholds the Affirmative Action program by a vote of four to three with Justice Elena Kagan taking no part in the consideration. I have been in support of it for a long time, but I know there is evidence out there pointing to the fact that it harms minorities such as Asians and others.

Next